Today's Taipei Times's editorial is well worth a read. The editorial titled, Token pledges on Earth Day, pretty much sums up environmental concerns over the path that president-elect Ma Ying-jeou seems to be following.
Wednesday, April 30, 2008
Token pledges on Earth Day- Ma's Road ?
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
11:17 AM
0
comments
Hushan Update
The Hushan Reservoir Public Hearing took place on Saturday April 26 in Douliou. We will be posting information on the hearing soon.
Fairy Pitta are still arriving in the Hushan-Huben area for the breeding season. Numbers in areas close to but outside the actual dam construction area appear to be lower this season but it is still too early to be certain. We will only be able to confirm this in about a month once the census is complete and figures can be compared to previous years. Areas away from the construction area appear to be showing good numbers.
The first Fairy Pitta banding capture took place yesterday. A male bird was netted on a research site fairly close to the construction area. The pitta was measured and banded before being released.
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
10:57 AM
0
comments
Wednesday, April 23, 2008
Hushan Conservation Measures Public Hearing This Saturday – Public Invited To “Participate”
By C.M.
The official Public Hearing on the Hushan Reservoir Ecological Conservation Measures will be held at 9am this Saturday (April 26, 2008) in Douliou (Touliu) Town Hall (38 Fuwen Road 府文路, Douliou City, Yunlin County, map in Chinese). This follows a preparatory hearing held last month where stakeholders met for a test run and to thrash out details such as the main focus of the discussion and the level of transparency and detail that was expected of the reservoir developer (the Central Region Water Resources Office (CRWRO)*) and Taiwan Endemic Species Research Insitute (TESRI ), the body commissioned to oversee and co-implement the Conservation Measures.
The official purpose of the meeting is to explain the current status of the Hushan Reservoir Ecological Conservation Measures, the design and implementation of which were one of the conditions upon which the project was approved. Environmental groups, experts, academics and local community representatives are free to attend, or “participate” as the public notice calls it, although public explanation meetings and hearings for EIAs in Taiwan usually allow only a very passive form of participation by the public, something better described as consultation of the public and the provision of an opportunity to comment, but not to directly influence decision-making.
Judith Petts, editor of the Handbook of Environmental Impact Assessment, describes some of the major differences between consultation and participation in EIA:
“Participation is a process of engagement, where people are enlisted into the decision process to contribute to it… Participation requires that those initiating the process are open to the potential need for change and are prepared to work with different interests to develop plans or to amend or even drop existing proposals…Consultation refers to the process of asking for information and comments about proposals...[and] often focuses more on the need of an authority or developer to consult other bodies and named individuals than the broader public. It is the top-down strategy, where the proponent or authority remains firmly in control and, in the public context, is mainly concerned with passing on information. It is often a one-way process…” (Petts, 1999).
Members of the public and environmental groups who attended the preparatory meeting in March expressed concern at the omissions in both the original EIA for the dam project (such as the failure to consider ecological impacts upstream of the dam), the inadequacy and poor planning of the Conservation Measures, and the risk posed by the project to the ecosystems of the Hushan area, including You-cing Valley.
Some dam proponents responded to the latter with the argument that the question of whether or not to build the dam and flood the valley had already been addressed during the EIA process and that it was too late to discuss the uniqueness and value of an intact You-cing Valley, and suggested that the hearing should focus on the Conservation Measures, which mainly involve capturing and translocating some plants and animals to a “restoration site” outside of the reservoir boundaries.
This debate over the focus of the up-coming meeting reflects the fact that project opponents feel that an inadequate and insufficiently participatory EIA for the Hushan Reservoir project left too many questions unanswered and allowed too little real participation in decision-making, leaving them no option but to continue to voice their concerns at this stage, with the project now already underway.
*-The Central Region Water Resources Office, Water Resources Agency, Ministry of Economic Affairs.
References:
Petts, Judith. 1999. Public Participation and EIA. In: J. Petts (ed.) Handbook of Environmental Impact Assessment (Vol. 1). Blackwell Science, pp. 145-177.
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
12:51 PM
0
comments
Tuesday, April 15, 2008
Fairy Pitta wintering area mystery continues
The Fairy Pitta wintering area mystery continues. Dr [Scott] Lin Reuy-shing of the Taiwan Endemic Research Institute (TESRI) has recently returned from a research trip to Sarawak, Borneo. No Fairy Pitta were seen or heard on the trip. He was able to follow up on the November 2007 Fairy Pitta sighting made by a Mr. Yeo in the area of the Matang Wildlife Centre. He was also able to study habitat on Sarawak.
The location of the Fairy Pitta's wintering area continues to elude us. It has long presumed to be the island of Borneo but that is somewhat of an educated guess. There have been a handful of confirmed winter Fairy Pitta sightings from Borneo so it would appear that at least some Fairy Pitta are present during winter.
Also see:
Search for the Fairy Pitta wintering area
Australia's first Fairy Pitta and a winter sighting on Borneo
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
11:43 AM
0
comments
Monday, April 14, 2008
Nestling Diet, Nest Site Selection and Nest Success of the Fairy Pitta in Taiwan
A recent doctoral dissertation on Nestling Diet, Nest Site Selection and Nest Success of the Fairy Pitta (Pitta nympha) in Taiwan by R.S. Lin.
*Note:- Introductory note of the dissertation is in Chinese but the actual paper follows in English.
Also see:
Recently Published Papers on the Fairy Pitta
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
3:25 PM
0
comments
Sunday, April 13, 2008
They're Back !
Fairy Pitta:-courtesy of Richard Yu.
Yes, they're back ! The first Fairy Pitta (Pitta nympha) of the season was heard calling yesterday afternoon in the forests outside Huben Village. Dr. [Scott] Lin Reuy-shing and his team from the Taiwan Endemic Species Research Institute (TESRI) are ready for this seasons research program. Joining this year's effort for the season will be Sylvester Karimi (Nairobi Museum, Kenya). We extend a warm welcome to Sylvester and look forward to working with him. In May Korean Fairy Pitta researcher, Eun-Mi Kim of the Jeju Wildlife Research Center will be joining the team for about a week as part of the cooperation effort between Taiwan and Korean based Fairy Pitta researchers.
In addition, Wild Bird Society of Yunlin will be supporting the research effort and Mark Wilkie of Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association will be coordinating international involvement in conservation efforts and assisting in the documentation and recording of events this season.
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
1:58 PM
0
comments
Saturday, April 12, 2008
Pigs of God: Contest of Cruelty
Taiwan National Coalition Against the Hushan Dam member Environment and Animal Society of Taiwan (EAST) together with the World Society for the Protection of Animals (WSPA) are hosting a campaign to end the inhumane 'Pigs of God' contest which causes extreme suffering. Pigs are confined and force fed for up to two years, reaching six times their normal weight. Most cannot walk or stand up and have to be hauled to slaughter by up to twenty men. The pigs are slaughtered in public while fully conscious.
We are delighted to let you know that WSPA's ‘Pigs of God’ campaign is making fantastic progress.
Virtual Success
To date, people from 60 different countries have shown their support by adding a flower to our virtual pig. These flower signatures, including yours, have already made a difference.
Flowers in action
In November, the Environment and Animal Society of Taiwan (EAST) presented a life-size pig made of flowers and candy to Taiwan’s San Shia Master Temple in an appeal to end its cruel Pigs of God contest (see picture above).
The event generated further support for the online petition at www.pigsofgod.org
Government shows compassion
After pressure from WSPA and member societies, the Taiwanese government has shown a willingness to be compassionate by strengthening the Animal Protection Act in 2007 and pledging to ban live bird markets from April 2008.
Let’s keep up the pressure!
Also see:
Peaceful protest calls for end to cruel contest
Pig that weighs more than a car in cruel contest
WSPA succeeds in changing Animal Protection law
Animal protection breakthrough in Taiwan
Campaign to stop pig cruelty in Taiwan
Undercover film reveals shocking pig cruelty in Taiwan
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
9:55 AM
0
comments
Friday, April 11, 2008
Planting trees to off-set emissions isn't going to do it
Land being reclaimed at the Formosa Plastics Plant to use for planting trees. The area being destroyed through the reclamation is valuable humpback dolphin habitat.
In today's Taipei Times Lee Ken-cheng*, director of Mercy on the Earth, Taiwan argues that there is not enough land to off-set emissions.
Lee notes how state-owned firms have been falling over themselves in their search for land to plant trees. He makes the point that forestation projects such as the 60,000-hectare forestation project proposed by President-elect, Ma Ying-jeou, would not really be effective in reducing carbon emissions. He tells how a 60,000-hectare forestation plan would be able to absorb 1 million tonnes of carbon emissions every year. This would not be able to offset even a tenth of the FPG steel refinery's carbon output.
Environmentalists see the benefits of reforestation but planting trees doesn't address the cause of high emissions. Emission levels need to be brought down. Trees should be planted to reforest areas that were previously forest. Why reclaim land from a valuable marine environment and home to a highly endangered species to plant trees to combat emissions? Reforestation should be done out of a desire to restore forests and their valuable ecosystems not as a green-washing tool to hide emissions and create the incorrect impression that something is being done.
*Lee Ken-cheng was a teacher in Kaohsiung for 17 years. He is the Executive Director of Mercy on the Earth, Taiwan and a former appointee to the Environmental Impact Assessment Committee.
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
12:56 PM
0
comments
Tuesday, April 8, 2008
Second Training Course for Volunteer Land-based Dolphin Observers and Interpretation Staff

Announcement: MFCU accepting applications for Second Training Course for Volunteer Land-based Dolphin Observers and Interpretation Staff.
The Matsu’s Fish Conservation Union (MFCU), comprised of seven leading non-profit environmental and research organizations, recently announced the opening two sessions of its annual training program to promote awareness of the plight of Taiwan’s highly endangered eastern Taiwan Strait population of Indo-Pacific humpback dolphins (Sousa chinensis). The dolphins inhabit the estuarine waters along Taiwan's west coast and are seriously threatened by human activities in, and impacts on, their habitat. The two-day training sessions will include lectures by leading cetacean scientists, ecologists and researchers of their history and habitat, threats to cetacean* survival and measures that can be taken to reduce the likelihood of the population’s extinction.
Directed primarily at persons who would like to participate in the awareness and conservation campaign, the first two sessions this year will be held a times roughly corresponding with the calming of the coastal waters that begins around the time of the birthday of the goddess of the sea, Matsu, which this year falls on 28 April (lunar calendar 23d day of the third month). See below for details:
Purpose of Training:
The aim of this year’s course is to train 40 volunteers (20 in each weekend course) to become land-based observers of the dolphins and help compile long-term observation records, which will contribute to understanding of the population. During the dolphin-watching season they may also provide support to interpretation activities and work as staff members.
Training Schedule:
1st session: 12 April 2008 (Saturday) to 13 April 2008 (full)
2nd session: 19 April 2008 (Saturday) to 20 April 2008 (places still available)
Location:
1st course: Providence University Fangjilousheng Classroom number 117, Number 20 Jhongci Road, Shalu Township, Taichung County (map).
2nd course: Fa-e-chaoren’s Home, Number 376, Haifong Road Section 2, Wugang Village, Taisi Township, Yunlin County (map).
※Note that depending on demand there will be more sessions scheduled throughout the coming months. All sessions are currently planned to be held in mandarin Chinese, however, if there is sufficient demand we will be happy to arrange for an English language course.
Application deadline:
There are still 5 places left for the second workshop, and we will stop accepting applications for that course once those places are filled.
Requirements:
Applicants must be at least 18 years old and enthusiastic about ecological conservation!
Training fee:
NT$ 800 (this includes the cost of handouts and insurance and a NT$500 deposit, which will be returned to the volunteer upon completion of the course and 10 hours of work. In the event that the trainee does not fulfill these requirements their deposit will go towards the Matsu’s Fish Conservation Fund where it may contribute to future training.
How to apply:
After submitting the training fee, we will send you a receipt and an application form (下載 Chinese copy also downloadable here), which you should email to cykan@ecology.org.tw or fax to (04)2653-0021, and your application will be complete.
How to pay:
By post office transfer to:
Account number: 22534681
Account Name: Taiwan Academy of Ecology
※Please be sure to add the following note on your payment slip: “Payment for Matsu’s Fish Training Course”
Description of work:
Ten hours of interpretation and compiling land-based observation records.
Lesson content:
Day 1
09:00~10:30:- An Introduction to Cetaceans,
Speaker: Ray Chin
10:50~12:00:- Current Conservation Status of Matsu’s Fish,
Speaker: Chen Bing-hen
13:20~15:00:- The State of Taiwan’s West Coast Ecology
Speaker: Tsai Chia-Yang
15:20~17:00:- West Coast Ecology Threats,
Speaker: Chen Bing-hen
Day 2
09:00~12:00:- Land-based Observation part I
13:20~17:00:- Land-based Observation part II
Introduction to speakers:
Chen Bing-hen: Taiwan Academy of Ecology Secretary General
Ray Chin : Kuroshio Ocean Education Foundation
Tsai: Chia-yang: Changhua Coastal Conservation Action
※ Please bring your own cup and chopsticks or other cutlery, and for the land-based observation please bring binoculars, a camera, drinking water, and be prepared to be under the hot sun!
Enquiry hotline:
Chinese: (04) 2632-8001 ext. 17054 (Miss A Gan of Taiwan Academy of Ecology)
English: 0938 643 410 (Chris, Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association).
* Cetacean: Belonging to the order Cetacea, an order of aquatic, chiefly marine mammals, which are whales, dolphins and porpoises.
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
11:37 PM
0
comments
Monday, April 7, 2008
TEPU calls on Taiwan's president-elect to focus on environmental issues
The Taiwan Environmental Protection Union (TEPU), one of Taiwan's leading environmental NGOs, has called on president-elect, Ma Ying-jeou, to focus on environmental issues. The outgoing Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) had many of its roots in the environmental movement. However, once in power, the DPP seemed to abandon its eco origins and left a very disappointing environmental track record. Previously under the Chinese National Party (KMT) the Environmental Protection Administration (EPA) was nothing more than a rubber stamp department and had an a abysmal track record for protecting the environment. With the return of the KMT on an economic ticket environmentalists are very concerned that the KMT will pick up where they left off and environmental destruction in the name of development will once again become the order of the day.
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
10:32 AM
0
comments
Monday, March 31, 2008
Taiwan Humpback Dolphin Training Program
Updated !!!: See MFCU accepting applications for Second Training Course for Volunteer Land-based Dolphin Observers and Interpretation Staff.
The Matsu Fish Conservation Union will be holding two sessions of its annual training program to promote awareness of the plight of a highly endangered Eastern Taiwan Strait population of Indo-Pacific humpback dolphins Sousa chinensis. The dolphins inhabit the estuarine waters along Taiwan's west coast and are seriously threatened by reclamation of estuarine and coastal regions for industrial purposes; by-catch in fishing gear; diversion and extraction of freshwater from major river systems of western Taiwan; release of industrial, agricultural and municipal effluent into rivers and coastal waters; noise and disturbance associated with construction, shipping and military activities.
The one-day-training-sessions will include lectures by leading cetacean scientists, researchers and ecologists on humpback dolphin history, habitat, threats and measures that can be taken to reduce the likelihood of the humpback dolphin's extinction.
The training program will be directed primarily at persons who would like to participate in our awareness and conservation campaigns. The first two sessions this year will be held a times roughly corresponding with the calming of the coastal waters that begins around the time of the birthday of the goddess of the sea, Matsu, which falls on 28 April this year (lunar calendar 23d day of the third month).
Session 1: 12 April 2008 Providence University, Taichung County.
Session 2: 19 April 2008 Yunlin County, Venue TBA.
All sessions are currently planned to be held in Mandarin Chinese, however, if there is sufficient demand (at least five persons) we will be happy to arrange for an English language course. Note that depending on demand there will be more sessions scheduled throughout the coming months.
For more details please e-mail us: comment@wildatheart.org.tw
Updated !!!: See MFCU accepting applications for Second Training Course for Volunteer Land-based Dolphin Observers and Interpretation Staff.
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
11:37 PM
0
comments
Buzzards and Butterflies - ecotourism opportunities going begging
A pair of Grey-faced Buzzard over Baguashan late yesterday afternoon. We spotted more then a thousand from our little observation hide yesterday afternoon along with a few Crested Serpent Eagle, Oriental Honey Buzzard, and Crested Goshawk.
Taiwan plunged 22 places on the Geneva-based World Economic Forum's (WEF) Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report for 2008. With more focus on environmental sustainability this year, Taiwan only managed to achieve the 103rd place for natural resources which sealed the nation's abysmal score.
From mid March to mid April west-central Taiwan hosts two spectacular natural events. Beginning in mid March thousands of raptors, mostly Grey-faced Buzzard Butastur indicus and Chinese Sparrowhawk Accipiter soloensis, migrate through Taiwan on their journey north and gather around the Baguashan area in west-central Taiwan. Starting in late March one of the largest butterfly migrations on the planet unfolds as multitudes of Purple Crow Butterflies (Euploea genus) migrate through Huben, Hushan and Ping Ding.
Most people have never heard of these amazing events. That's not surprising considering that very little effort is made by the Taiwan Government to promote these events internationally and develop the ecotourism potential they offer. We've yet to see a single foreign face other than a Taiwan-based foreign naturalist at both these events this year. It was the same story last year and the year before.
The authorities should really be looking at the ecotourism potential of the Huben-Hushan area and the adjoining Baguashan area rather than trashing these environmentally important areas and using them as an opportunity to breathe new life into Taiwan's declining tourism industry.A Grey-faced Buzzard over Baguashan yesterday.
Not specs of dust. Grey-faced Buzzard high over Baguashan yesterday.
See:
Huben and the Purple Butterflies
A Brief History of Grey-Faced Buzzard Conservation in Taiwan
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
12:50 PM
0
comments
Saturday, March 29, 2008
Search for the Fairy Pitta wintering area
The location of the Fairy Pitta's wintering area remains somewhat of a mystery. It has long presumed to be the island of Borneo but in reality that is somewhat of an educated guess. There are a handful of confirmed winter Fairy Pitta sightings from Borneo so it would appear that at least some Fairy Pitta are present during winter.
Dr Lin Reuy-shing of the Taiwan Endemic Research Institute is presently in Sarawak, Borneo, following up on a November 2007 Fairy Pitta sighting made in the area of the Matang Wildlife Centre. We wish him success and eagerly await word of how he's been getting on.
Update !
See: Fairy Pitta wintering area mystery continues
Also see:
Australia's first Fairy Pitta and a winter sighting on Borneo
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
10:58 AM
0
comments
Friday, March 28, 2008
Hushan Hearing Rescheduled to Allow More Preparation
At a preparatory hearing held on Monday 24th March in Wufeng Township, Taichung County, it was decided that the official public hearing concerning conservation measures to accompany the Hushan Reservoir project in Yunlin County, originally scheduled for the following Monday (31st March), would be postponed. Yesterday the Water Resources Agency (WRA) announced that the meeting will now be held on Saturday 26 April. See the Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association website for details.
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
4:33 PM
0
comments
Sunday, March 23, 2008
More reflections on the destruction at Hushan
For more on the recent NGO visit to the Hushan Dam site see Reflections on the destruction at Hushan on the Wild website.
Also see:
Hushan Dam: NGO site visit
Hushan Dam site visit: Photos
The destruction continues
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
5:34 PM
0
comments
Thursday, March 13, 2008
Environmental sustainability concerns cause Taiwan to free fall on the global tourism chart
What would you rather see ?
This ?
....or this ?
Taiwan has plunged 22 places on the Geneva-based World Economic Forum's (WEF) Travel and Tourism Competitiveness Report for 2008.
"Environmental sustainability" was given greater importance this year and Taiwan only managed to come in at an extremely poor 75th in the index of environmental sustainability. Weaknesses in "health and hygiene" (ranking 101st) and "natural resources" (103rd) also contributed to the nation's abysmal score.
Taiwan, with one of the highest levels of biodiversity per square kilometre on the planet should be looking to preserve its amazing natural heritage. Taiwan, with the highest mountains in East Asia, boasts climatic zones from tropical all the way to subarctic tundra. Taiwan is a living laboratory of almost all of Asia's climatic zones. To see what would take thousands of kilometres worth of travel on mainland Asia can be done by traveling just a few hundred kilometres on Taiwan.
Taiwan should be developing its unique natural heritage for ecotourism not trashing it in the race to become the world's leader in per capita CO2 emissions.
See the Taipei Times for the story.
Also see:
The Cost of Taiwan's Development
Taiwan's Wuchi Power Plant - the world's dirtiest
Government to reduce CO2 emissions in Taiwan to 2000 levels
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
12:11 PM
0
comments
Integrity of the EPA review group under the spotlight again
The Environmental Protection Administration's (EPA) Environmental Review Committee (ERC) has once again come under the spotlight. It is alleged that members colluded with construction companies to approve proposals.
The appointment of the seventh committee in mid 2007 was controversial with all five true environmentalists that served on the sixth committee being replaced by, what many perceived to be, pro-development academics and experts who will likely do the government's bidding on controversial projects.
Six of the 11 ERC members responsible for reviewing the construction proposal for the Heping coal-burning power plant in Hualien County have been accused of taking cash to approve the project.
See the Taipei Times for the story.
Also see: The seventh Environmental Impact Assessment Committee of Great Concern to Environmentalists
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
11:55 AM
0
comments
Wednesday, March 12, 2008
Hushan Dam site visit: Photos
Hushan Dam site: 3 March 2008.
Same area as above, 4 February 2007.
Same area as above, 14 June 2007.
Hushan Dam site visit: 3 March 2008
Hushan, as it was !
See: Hushan Dam: NGO site visit
Also see:
Reflections on the destruction at Hushan
The destruction continues
For some earlier photos of construction work at the Hushan Dam site click here.
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
11:29 PM
0
comments
Friday, March 7, 2008
WSPA membership for Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association

We are delighted to learn that Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association , a very active member of our Taiwan National Coalition Against the Hushan Dam, have been accepted as a World Society for the Protection of Animals (WSPA) member society.
"The World Society for the Protection of Animals (WSPA) is the world’s largest network for animal welfare. It brings together over 880 member societies in 153 countries and a whole community of individuals around the world who care about animal welfare." - WSPA International
Wild becomes the third Taiwan based WSPA member society. The three Taiwan based WSPA member societies are EAST (Environment and Animal Society of Taiwan); Life Conservationist Association; and most recently Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association. Wild has cooperated with and worked alongside EAST a number of times in the past and they both remain members of the Taiwan National Coalition Against the Hushan Dam.
We congratulate Wild on their WSPA membership and look forward to WSPA and their member societies involvement in the Hushan Dam-Fairy Pitta issue, the plight of the Taiwan humpback dolphins, and other Taiwan issues.
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
1:41 PM
0
comments
Hushan Dam: NGO site visit
Hushan, as it appears now. March 3, 2008 NGO visit.
On the morning of Monday, 3rd March, various NGOs and individuals had a meeting in Douliou City before going to visit the Hushan Dam site later in the day. Amongst others were Taiwan National Coalition Against the Hushan Dam (TNCAHD) representatives from Taiwan Environmental Protection Union (TEPU), Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association, Taiwan Academy of Ecology, and Wild Bird Society of Yunlin.
At 13:30 NGOs, press and concerned individuals met with the Central Region Water Resources Office (CRWRO) of the Water Resources Agency at their offices in Hushan. What follows are some general impressions and observations made by a TNCAHD member present.
The Central Region Water Resources Office hosted a meeting/presentation in an old classroom in the former Trans-World College Campus in Hushan. Central Region Water Resources Office Deputy Director, Chiang Ming-Lang, seemed to be in charge of proceedings and stood handing out business cards while for a time a large image of the Taipei 101 building appeared on the presentation screen in the meeting room as the visitors arrived.
Chiang and his office seemed ill prepared for the for the presence of members of the international community. No interpreter was available nor was any non-Mandarin material or information available. Considering the international interest in the Hushan issue and the considerable numbers of letters of concern sent to the Taiwanese Government by large international groups like BirdLife International, The Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB), The Humane Society International (HSI), and National Resources Defense Council (NRDC) this was the first in a number of observations that tended to give the impression of a very inward looking and closed-minded attitude of the CRWRO in their dealings with NGOs and other non-governmental individuals or groups. English has been called the unofficial "second language" of Taiwan. Some government departments religiously prepare some English material for presentations where they know or expect foreign involvement but this differs from department to department.
At the presentation the thirty-strong visiting group, made up of concerned individuals and members of the press and NGOs, seemed to be almost outnumbered by seemingly uninvolved CRWRO and Taisei Corporation workers. During the presentation a number of these people would walk in and out of the classroom and would gather in small groups outside smoking and chatting while staring through the windows at the visitors. Was this perhaps an attempt at intimidation or just too many under-worked CRWRO bureaucrats with nothing better to fill their day with than the opportunity of staring at all the environmentalists that had come to view their handiwork? Bored bureaucrats ?
The presentation included slides of officials allegedly saving creatures, such as the endangered Yellow-margined Box Turtle Cuora flavomarginata flavomarginata, and a number of indigenous plants. The attitude seemed to be one of, "You see ! We did it right ! We helped save all those little creatures you were so worried about. We know we didn't let you come and watch us because we didn't want you interfering with our important development but trust us, we know what we're doing so what was all the fuss about?"
The Presentation
After the presentation the visitors were handed bright yellow hardhats. Our CRWRO and Taisei hosts wore red or orange ones. Visitors were then put on bus and a minivan and escorted by a few private cars, were driven to the dam site. The vehicles whizzed past workings that our hosts had obviously decided were not to be viewed regardless of whether we had an interest in these specific working areas or not. The full impact of a cleared Hushan was quite a shock. Hills stood treeless and clear of vegetation. Much of Hushan, as we knew it, now lay in ruins, gone forever !
Visitors were taken to only two working areas. At the second area an official working on the "conservation" and "rehabilitation" of the area lamented to the media how environmentalists continually interfere with his work. Quite how environmentalists interfere with his work on a site that they are bared from entering was not explained. The concept of non-governmental-parties having concerns for what was being done behind closed doors on the site and how it was being done didn't seem to be a legitimate reason to question his work. He clearly seemed to think he was only accountable to government and the developers. The fact that a considerable some of money, around 200 million NT Dollars, has been earmarked for "conservation" and "rehabilitation" on the project and that the public should have a right to know how that money is being spent, again, didn't appear to count for very much. Clearing Hushan
Visitors were then taken to an area outside the construction area and shown a very small cleared area set amongst exotic bamboo and betel nut palms. Within the cleared area totaling a few hundred square metres, if that, were a few plants. This, we were told, was what they had saved from the construction site. We were made to understand that some trees still had to be moved but somehow, after having viewed the hundreds of hectares of cleared land, these few plants didn't seem very much.
The saved plants
Click for site visit photos.
Also see:
Reflections on the destruction at Hushan on the Wild at Heart website.
The destruction continues
Posted by
Wild at Heart Legal Defense Association
at
12:46 PM
0
comments